Love the idea, but the colors don't scream pirates at all. For me pirates colors are blacks, gold, red, burgundy... dark colors. Pastel colors? Meh!
I do have to accept that I'm a sucker for purples, so for me Planks A Lots is really pretty. I do love the Silver Shatter a lot!
For me it's really hard to find OPI nail polishes. In Puerto Rico we don't get much of them. In fact, I still haven't seen the black shatter. Probably I would never get to try one of these colors, but a girl can dream.